Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum
Odie
Member+
Posts: 6918
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Odie » Today, 16:42

This is a piece from Walelign Makonen's article that cost him his life by Amhara supremacists that were amharnizing all ethnics including Eritrea for their glory and economic gain :mrgreen:


What are the Ethiopian people composed of? I stress on the word peoples because sociologically speaking at this stage Ethiopia is not really one nation. It is made up of a dozen nationalities with their own languages, ways of dressing, history, social organization and territorial 2 entity. And what else is a nation? It is not made of a people with a particular tongue, particular ways of dressing, particular history, particular social and economic organization? Then may I conclude that in Ethiopia there is the Oromo Nation, the Tigrai Nation, the Amhara Nation, the Gurage Nation, the Sidama Nation, the Wellamo [Wolayta] Nation, the Adere [Harari] Nation, and however much you may not like it the Somali Nation. This is the true picture of Ethiopia. There is of course the fake Ethiopian Nationalism advanced by the ruling class and unwillingly accepted and even propagated by innocent fellow travellers. What is this fake Nationalism? Is it not simply Amhara and to a certain extent Amhara-Tigre supremacy? Ask anybody what Ethiopian culture is? Ask anybody what Ethiopian language is? Ask anybody what Ethiopian music is? Ask anybody what the "national dress" is? It is either Amhara or Amhara-Tigre!! To be a "genuine Ethiopian" one has to speak Amharic, to listen to Amharic music, to accept the Amhara-Tigre religion, Orthodox Christianity and to wear the Amhara-Tigre Shamma in international conferences. In some cases to be an "Ethiopian", you will even have to change your name. In short to be an Ethiopian, you will have to wear an Amhara mask (to use Fanon's expression) :lol: :lol: . Start asserting your national identity and you are automatically a tribalist, that is if you are not blessed to be born an Amhara :lol: :lol: . According to the constitution you will need Amharic to go to school, to get a job, to read books (however few) and even to listen to the news on Radio "Ethiopia" unless you are a Somali or an Eritrean in Asmara for obvious reasons. To anybody who has got a nodding acquaintenance with Marxism, culture is nothing more than the super-structure of an economic basis. So cultural domination always presupposes economic subjugation. A clear example of economic subjugation would be the Amhara and to a certain extent Tigrai Neftegna system in the South and the AmharaTigre Coalition in the urban areas. The usual pseudo-refutation of this analysis is the reference to the large Amhara andd Tigrai masses wallowing in poverty in the countryside. For that matter during the heydays of British imperialism a large mass of British Workers had to live under inhuman conditions. Another popular counter argument is that there are two or three ministers of non-amhara-Tigre Nationality in the Cabinet, one or two generals in the army, one or two governors and a dozen balabats in the countryside (still works tody) :lol: :lol: . But out and out imperialists like the British used to rule their colonies mainly by enlisting the support of tribal chiefs, who were much more rich than the average citizen of the British Metropolis. The 3 fact that (Houphet) Boigne and Senghor were members of the French National Assembly and the fact that they were even ministers did not reduce an iota of Senegalese and Ivory Coast [Ivoirians] loss of political independence. Of course the economic and cultural subjugation by the Amharas and their junior partners the Tigres is a historical accident. Amharas are not dominant because of inherent imperialist tendencies. The Oromos could have done it, the Wellamos [Wolaytas] could have done it and history proves they tried to do so. But that is not an excuse for the perpetuation of this situation. The immediate question is we must declare a stop to it. And we must build a genuine national- state. And what is this genuine national-state? It is a state in which all nationalities participate equally in state affairs, it is a state where every nationality is given equal opportunity to preserve and develop its language, its music and its history. It is a state where Amharas, Tigres, Oromos, Aderes [Harari], Somalis, Wollamos [Wolaytas], Gurages, etc. are treated equally. It is a state where no nation dominates another nation be it economically or culturally.

Odie
Member+
Posts: 6918
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Odie » Today, 17:08

Anybody who aspires to sit in the driver sit of 4 KILO must read this article (hopefully all read it but they focus on stabilizing their power--they don't care about the rest :mrgreen: ); know the disparities, the past misrule and develop an all-inclusive ideology (not hegemony) and change wrongs to right. Unfortunately, the Amhara-Tigre supremacy is now kind of replaced with Oromo supremacy. Many ethnics still suffer the brunt of the oppression by Aramuma. For example, Gurage that disserved a kilil is flatly denied by the Bashasha king. Now the country is being misruled by the bashasha errand boy and his aramuma thug. Even worse, the Fano, gelada baboon aspires to bring back Mote-anbesa or the old empire glory of the dead kings than ushering in modern ideology and leadership. What a cursed country :lol:
Ethiopia just needs decentralized, democratic federal system best using geographic system of federalism or ethnic federalism-if done properly- (RISKY!) based on civil right, citizen right and strong institutions and accountability in place.

Dama
Member+
Posts: 7414
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Dama » Today, 20:06

P*mpamara won't debate this. It's beyond their lovel of literacy.

Odie
Member+
Posts: 6918
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Odie » Today, 20:49

Dama wrote:
Today, 20:06
P*mpamara won't debate this. It's beyond their lovel of literacy.
Unfortunate. I had a good impression of them (Hoping they might come up with all-inclusive and new idea, (not the old dead imperial system) but some of the thugs on this forum just reminded me of the old bad days and some of the radical un-answered questions I had. I am not a supporter of any particular group but wish well for anybody/group who does the right thing for everybody (all ethnics/citizens) and for the country. Unless all polarized groups come together in civilized way and resolve this unending power struggle and conflict/ethnic supremacist ideology, the country will continue to impoverish or even worse become failed state or disintegrate.

Dama
Member+
Posts: 7414
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Dama » 58 minutes ago

Odie wrote:
Today, 20:49
Dama wrote:
Today, 20:06
P*mpamara won't debate this. It's beyond their lovel of literacy.
Unfortunate. I had a good impression of them (Hoping they might come up with all-inclusive and new idea, (not the old dead imperial system) but some of the thugs on this forum just reminded me of the old bad days and some of the radical un-answered questions I had. I am not a supporter of any particular group but wish well for anybody/group who does the right thing for everybody (all ethnics/citizens) and for the country. Unless all polarized groups come together in civilized way and resolve this unending power struggle and conflict/ethnic supremacist ideology, the country will continue to impoverish or even worse become failed state or disintegrate.
Peaceful political parties try their best under the tyranny of supreme dictator Abiy Ahmed. They get harassed, their offices searched and latops and phones confiscated for investihations, they get arrested. Some get released and others still languish in prison. All these are Addis Abeba based. Melted pots..sort of amharanized individuals from diverse ethnic groups who may or may not speak a language pther than Amharic.

The ethno-nationalists are in the jungles of Amara, Oromo, Ogaden and Benishangul. TPLF is the ruling ethnic party, no longer in the jungle. SLF, the Sidama liberation front, which never killed one Ethiopian soldier during DERG or EPRDF is the ruling political party of Sidama...its members had dual membership with EPRDF and SLF. For some secret reason, Meles and Aba Dula who ruled SNNP tolerated it.
On Gurage the Kistane Liberation FrontKLF) is ruling Gurage to oversea the weakening of Gurage by supporting Kushiting minority terrorists against Gurage. Dr.Endashew Tasew also created vicious division between two of East Gurage groups, Mesqan and Dobi. Adding the Dobi hated to Mesqan eboldens Mareqo that has been terrorizing Mesqan Gurage.

Odie
Member+
Posts: 6918
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: Was this Amhara some call him Oromo, confused or brilliant soul or a naive Marxist?

Post by Odie » 49 minutes ago

Dama wrote:
58 minutes ago
Odie wrote:
Today, 20:49
Dama wrote:
Today, 20:06
P*mpamara won't debate this. It's beyond their lovel of literacy.
Unfortunate. I had a good impression of them (Hoping they might come up with all-inclusive and new idea, (not the old dead imperial system) but some of the thugs on this forum just reminded me of the old bad days and some of the radical un-answered questions I had. I am not a supporter of any particular group but wish well for anybody/group who does the right thing for everybody (all ethnics/citizens) and for the country. Unless all polarized groups come together in civilized way and resolve this unending power struggle and conflict/ethnic supremacist ideology, the country will continue to impoverish or even worse become failed state or disintegrate.
Peaceful political parties try their best under the tyranny of supreme dictator Abiy Ahmed. They get harassed, their offices searched and latops and phones confiscated for investihations, they get arrested. Some get released and others still languish in prison. All these are Addis Abeba based. Melted pots..sort of amharanized individuals from diverse ethnic groups who may or may not speak a language pther than Amharic.

The ethno-nationalists are in the jungles of Amara, Oromo, Ogaden and Benishangul. TPLF is the ruling ethnic party, no longer in the jungle. SLF, the Sidama liberation front, which never killed one Ethiopian soldier during DERG or EPRDF is the ruling political party of Sidama...its members had dual membership with EPRDF and SLF. For some secret reason, Meles and Aba Dula who ruled SNNP tolerated it.
On Gurage the Kistane Liberation FrontKLF) is ruling Gurage to oversea the weakening of Gurage by supporting Kushiting minority terrorists against Gurage. Dr.Endashew Tasew also created vicious division between two of East Gurage groups, Mesqan and Dobi. Adding the Dobi hated to Mesqan eboldens Mareqo that has been terrorizing Mesqan Gurage.
Hopeless scenario :lol: :lol:

Post Reply