Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum
Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

What was the origin of the Karrayu before they were forcefully assimilated by the invading Oromo?

Post by Revelations » 29 Mar 2024, 16:55

Only answer if you know.




Last edited by Revelations on 30 Mar 2024, 12:15, edited 1 time in total.



Noble Amhara
Senior Member
Posts: 13521
Joined: 02 Feb 2020, 13:00
Location: Abysinnia

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Noble Amhara » 29 Mar 2024, 17:27

Karayu are not assimilated they are actual pure descandents of the Borana Hordes that migrated into central Ethiopia they maintain the true culture of their forefather Baranto the lowlanderu they settled on Afar lands and have a drop of afar culture

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Revelations » 29 Mar 2024, 17:40

Before they got assimilated by the Oromo is what needs answering. Many others have been swallowed and the Karrayu are one such group.
Noble Amhara wrote:
29 Mar 2024, 17:27
Karayu are not assimilated they are actual pure descandents of the Borana Hordes that migrated into central Ethiopia they maintain the true culture of their forefather Baranto the lowlanderu

Misraq
Senior Member
Posts: 16746
Joined: 27 Sep 2009, 19:43
Location: Zemunda

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Misraq » 29 Mar 2024, 17:49

Harlaa

Noble Amhara
Senior Member
Posts: 13521
Joined: 02 Feb 2020, 13:00
Location: Abysinnia

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Noble Amhara » 29 Mar 2024, 18:08

Misraq wrote:
29 Mar 2024, 17:49
Harlaa
Harla lived across Hararghe especially in western Hararghe so todays Ituu Oromo clan descends from Harla and as well Karayu but what is the difference between Ituu clan and Karayu clan? Which one is more Oromo? The awnser is the one which is more like the Borana!

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Revelations » 29 Mar 2024, 18:44

Absolutely not the question. Why are you bending out of shape to divert the discussion? No, the question is not if they are more Oromo or not? The question is which tribe got swallowed by the invading Oromos of 16th century to become Karrayu of today.

Noble Amhara wrote:
29 Mar 2024, 18:08


Harla lived across Hararghe especially in western Hararghe so todays Ituu Oromo clan descends from Harla and as well Karayu but what is the difference between Ituu clan and Karayu clan? Which one is more Oromo? The awnser is the one which is more like the Borana!

Misraq
Senior Member
Posts: 16746
Joined: 27 Sep 2009, 19:43
Location: Zemunda

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Misraq » 29 Mar 2024, 19:43

I wouldn't rule out Afar since Kereyuu live in a similar life style of Afars. Both Harlaa and Afar are candidates due to the geographical location of present day Kereyuu

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Revelations » 29 Mar 2024, 22:02

Misraq wrote:
29 Mar 2024, 17:49
Harlaa

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Revelations » 30 Mar 2024, 01:45

According to some, the Karrayyu and Ittu clans are considered to be Oromos with Harla descent.[60] Ittu had occupied the Chercher region from the Harari people and perhaps also Harla.[61] It is believed the extinct Harla were incorporated into Karrayyu and Ittu in eastern Shewa as well as west Hararghe.[62][63]

The Afar also have tribes linked to Harla descent called Kabirtu.[64] In the seventeenth century the Harla of Afar Region were assimilated by Afar people following the collapse of Adal Sultanate.[65] In Afar region, clans named after Harla are still found among farmers in Aussa, and Awash district between Dubti and Afambo. The moniker of clans proposes a fusion between native and immigrating tribes.[66]


Cave painting attributed to Harla near Harar

According to historian Richard Wilding Harla were ancient Cushitic[2] however ethnologist Ulrich Braukämper suggests a Semitic variation which he labels "Harala-Harari" later developed in the Islamic period. Harala-Harari speakers were evidently disrupted by the Oromo migrations, leading to isolated related Semitic languages of Harari surviving in the walled city of Harar, Zay language on the island of Lake Zway and in parts of eastern Gurage territory such as Siltʼe language.[5]

Nicholas Tait proposes Harla language was indistinguishable with Argobba and Harari linguistic classifications.[67] Ewald Wagner believes Harla were Semitic speakers related to Harari and Silte languages.[68]

Field research by Enrico Cerulli identified a modern group called the "Harla" living amongst the Somali in the region between the cities of Harar and Jijiga. Encyclopaedia Aethiopica suggests that this population "may be a remnant group of the old [Harla], that integrated into the Somali genealogical system, but kept a partially separate identity by developing a language of their own." Cerulli published some data on this Harla community's language, called af Harlaad, which resembled the Somali languages spoken by the Yibir and Madhiban low-caste groups.[69]

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Revelations » 30 Mar 2024, 02:08

The Oromo expansions, also known as the Oromo migrations or the Oromo invasions[3][4] (in older historiography, Galla invasions[5][6][7]), were a series of expansions in the 16th and 17th centuries by the Oromo. Prior to their great expansion in the 16th century, the Oromo inhabited only the area of what is now modern-day southern Ethiopia and northern Kenya.[1] Over the centuries due to many factors, mostly the wars between Adal Sultanate and Ethiopia would further encourage the numerous Oromo tribes to expand towards central and eastern modern Ethiopia.[8]

Gudifecha adoption tradition also lead to massive diversification within Oromo populations as they expanded during the 16th century.[8]


Oromo territory located south of present-day Ethiopia on the eve of the Oromo invasions

Misraq
Senior Member
Posts: 16746
Joined: 27 Sep 2009, 19:43
Location: Zemunda

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Misraq » 30 Mar 2024, 02:51

Oromo destroyed 28 ethnic groups harlaa being one.
Oromo reduced Harari to minority of 40k people
Oromo reduced the big Hadiya territory to a minority
Oromo is halted by Amharas and actually reversed by the time of Menilik. Menilik should have destroyed Oromo or should have placed them to minority level. Oromo is now trying hard to destroy Amhara or put them to minority level. But like before, it won't succeed.

Horus
Senior Member+
Posts: 40413
Joined: 19 Oct 2013, 19:34

Re: What is the origin of the assimilated Karrayu?

Post by Horus » 30 Mar 2024, 03:05

I have a short old word list of Harari (Adere) language and I matched about 20% of the words with Kistane Gurage language. I have also heard oral stories some Kistane clans originating from Harar. For example, ሄራሌ is a personal name among Kistane Gurages,
Revelations wrote:
30 Mar 2024, 01:45
According to some, the Karrayyu and Ittu clans are considered to be Oromos with Harla descent.[60] Ittu had occupied the Chercher region from the Harari people and perhaps also Harla.[61] It is believed the extinct Harla were incorporated into Karrayyu and Ittu in eastern Shewa as well as west Hararghe.[62][63]

The Afar also have tribes linked to Harla descent called Kabirtu.[64] In the seventeenth century the Harla of Afar Region were assimilated by Afar people following the collapse of Adal Sultanate.[65] In Afar region, clans named after Harla are still found among farmers in Aussa, and Awash district between Dubti and Afambo. The moniker of clans proposes a fusion between native and immigrating tribes.[66]


Cave painting attributed to Harla near Harar

According to historian Richard Wilding Harla were ancient Cushitic[2] however ethnologist Ulrich Braukämper suggests a Semitic variation which he labels "Harala-Harari" later developed in the Islamic period. Harala-Harari speakers were evidently disrupted by the Oromo migrations, leading to isolated related Semitic languages of Harari surviving in the walled city of Harar, Zay language on the island of Lake Zway and in parts of eastern Gurage territory such as Siltʼe language.[5]

Nicholas Tait proposes Harla language was indistinguishable with Argobba and Harari linguistic classifications.[67] Ewald Wagner believes Harla were Semitic speakers related to Harari and Silte languages.[68]

Field research by Enrico Cerulli identified a modern group called the "Harla" living amongst the Somali in the region between the cities of Harar and Jijiga. Encyclopaedia Aethiopica suggests that this population "may be a remnant group of the old [Harla], that integrated into the Somali genealogical system, but kept a partially separate identity by developing a language of their own." Cerulli published some data on this Harla community's language, called af Harlaad, which resembled the Somali languages spoken by the Yibir and Madhiban low-caste groups.[69]

Revelations
Senior Member+
Posts: 34573
Joined: 06 Jan 2007, 15:44

Re: What was the origin of the Karrayu? before they were forcefully assimilated by the invading Oromo?

Post by Revelations » 30 Mar 2024, 12:13





Harar city fortifications originally erected in the sixteenth century following the Oromo invasions

Post Reply