Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum
DefendTheTruth
Senior Member
Posts: 12902
Joined: 08 Mar 2014, 16:32

መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by DefendTheTruth » 05 Oct 2024, 04:05

ሁለቱም ድንቅ በኣላት ናቸዉ፣ ደማቅ ናቸዉ፣ የኢትዮጵያነት መገለጫ ናቸዉ፣ የባሕል ና ሀይማኖት መገለጫዎች ናቸዉ፣ ሁለቱም የአለም የማይዳሰሱ ቅርፆች ናቸዉ፣ በዚህ ተመዝግቦዋል።

ግን አንድ ልዩነት በግልፅ ይታየኛል፣ በሁለቱ አከባበር ላይ።

መስቀል ልሙጥነትን ወይም ደግሞ አንድ አይነትነትን ያገዝፋል፣ በአንድ ማዕከል ይመራል፣ በአንድ ዶክትርን ማለት ይቻል ይሆናል፣ በላሙያዉ ስላልሆንኩኝ ግን ብዙም መፍረድ አልፈልግም።

ኢሬቻ ደግሞ በብዝሃትነት ነዉ የተመሰረተዉ፣ አንድ አይነትነትን የለዉም፣ የተለየዩ ቀለማት አንድ ላይ መጥቶ ያደምቁታል፣ ድምቀቱ ከብዝሃት ነዉ የምመነጨዉ፣ በተመሳሳይነት ላይ አይደለም የተመሰረተዉ፣ አንድ ማዕከል የለዉም፣ መሪዎቹ ከተለያዩ ቦታ ና ከተለያዩ አመለካከቶች ነዉ የምመነጨዉ፣ ሁሉም እንደመሰለዉ ያከብረዋል፣ እንድህ ሁን የምለዉ ማዕከለዊ ስልጣን የለዉም፣ መመሪያዉ የኦሮሞ የቆየ ና እግዚያብሔርን የማመስገን ተልዕኮ ብቻ ነው ያለዉ። ሁሉም እንደመሰለዉ ፈጣሪዉን ማመስገን ና መማፀን ይችላል፣ በዚህ ሆነህ፣ እንደዚህ አድርገህ የምለዉ የለም።

ብዝሃነት የፈጠረዉ የብዝሃነት መገለጫ፣ ኢሬቻ፣ መደሰቻ!


DefendTheTruth
Senior Member
Posts: 12902
Joined: 08 Mar 2014, 16:32

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by DefendTheTruth » 05 Oct 2024, 04:29

The lack of centralized coordination and control mechanism could risk a potential abuse and divergence of the goal of the celebration of irrecha in the long run, while Meskel could outlive and sustain itself due to its central tight control of the ceremony, like it did for 100s of years so far.

At the same time an Ethiopian life should be reflective of the diverse society we have been all along and try to encompass diversity in unity, in which case Irrecha could outshine Meskel in the long run much easily. It is simply more reflective of the reality on the ground and thereby more attractive than the more of centrally controlled extravagance of Meskel.

Economically both are worth of celebrating and luxuries for the city of Addis annual revenue, implying good news for more Corridor developments in the future.

Meta Chore
Member
Posts: 74
Joined: 09 Jan 2022, 13:03

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Meta Chore » 05 Oct 2024, 05:37

DDT,
Stop competing religious holidays of different ethnic groups.
Holidays are celebrated for reasons but not competition.
The current government is trying its best helping the Oromos to outperform the other ethnic groups in celebrating holidays.
It is wrong.

Noble Amhara
Senior Member
Posts: 13495
Joined: 02 Feb 2020, 13:00
Location: Abysinnia

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Noble Amhara » 05 Oct 2024, 06:08

Dendo

Tewahedo Meskel can only be compared to Tawheed Eid Al Mubarak

by the way Tewahedo and Tawheed meaning is similar tawheed= "Oneness of God / tewahedo = United as one

Ireecha is more like Tigrays Ashenda or Gojams Engicha or Selales Gobiye/shinoye its a oromo ethno-cultural festival mixed with a bit of Waaqafana religion. Ireccha is not a fully religious festival that is why it's decentralized because it is ethnically based that includes Pente, Muslim and Orthodox Oromos. now its being marketted not only to all oromo but all biher biheresebs and now it being declared a holiday for peace and unity




Axumezana
Senior Member
Posts: 18479
Joined: 27 Jan 2020, 23:15

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Axumezana » 05 Oct 2024, 06:55

Irrecha is demon worship day in the open air & has nothing to do with Meskel !

Odie
Member+
Posts: 6197
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Odie » 05 Oct 2024, 07:42

1. ኢሬቻ የበታችነት ስሜት ማስታገሻ የኦሮሙማ የፖለቲካ ድጋፍ ማስባስብያ የስይጣን ማምለክያ ጉባኤ ነው::

2. ኖብል አማራ ሃይማኖትህ ምን እንደሆነ ባላውቅምየክርስትናና የ እስላም በአል አከባበር ማነፃፀር ስተት ነው:: ስው የሚቀራረቡ ይመስለዋል ግን በጣም የተለያዩ exclude የሚደራረጉ ሃይማኖቶች ናቸው:: ልዩነታቸውን በጥልቅ የማያውቅ ስው ተቀራራቢ እምነቶች ይመስሉታል::

ዲዲቲ ስለኤሬቻ ከሌሎች ሃይማኖቶች አቀራርበህ የፖለቲካ ጥቅም ለማግኘት የምትሞክረው ፉርሽ ነው :lol:
ከራስህ ስዎች በቀር የሚስማህ አይኖርም::


DefendTheTruth
Senior Member
Posts: 12902
Joined: 08 Mar 2014, 16:32

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by DefendTheTruth » 05 Oct 2024, 08:09

Noble Amhara wrote:
05 Oct 2024, 06:08
Dendo

This is beautiful, I didn't doubt about it. There is also no doubt that the celebration is centrally choreographed, that is why it is so monotonous and similar all over the places, you can't see such a monoton scenery in the Irrecha celebration, the centers of the crowd are much smaller, of different tones and hues. Here you hear Afan Oromo, meters away you here a different language, the rhythms vary constantly, the blessings have no central guides, except that it is praying to the Almighty using one's own words. Abbaa Gadaa has no control over what people have to say or sing, which attire to put on or anything similar.

Diverse Irrecha, reflection of the mosaic nature of Ethiopia, i think.

I really like the beautiful varicolored closings of the festival.

Odie
Member+
Posts: 6197
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Odie » 05 Oct 2024, 08:57

Selam/ wrote:
05 Oct 2024, 07:52
>>>>>>>>>>>>
One sensible person!

DefendTheTruth
Senior Member
Posts: 12902
Joined: 08 Mar 2014, 16:32

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by DefendTheTruth » 05 Oct 2024, 09:36

Axumezana wrote:
05 Oct 2024, 06:55
Irrecha is demon worship day in the open air & has nothing to do with Meskel !
There is a saying I remember I think in Afan Oromo, originally:

"ሃዳ ነም ኢሺ ፎክፍቱ አረብሰኒ፣ ሃዳ ኡፊ ኢሺ በሬዱ አረብሥሱ".

it is sort of saying "if you insult somebody's ugly mother, then you invite also the others to insult your own beautiful mother", assuming there is an ugly mother to begin with.

If you consider Irrecha is demon and you can substantiate that with tangible evidence, then come forward and make your case for others to see.

Failing to do that, you are also invited to clean yourself from the demon that has engulfed you since your origin as a life on the planet before trying to bake to your level about something you have hardly any understanding about it.

That is fair enough disposition to your uncalled for tantrum on the internet.

Anyhow was the demon you saw in Irrecha revealed to you before or after you drove perhaps 100s of thousands of the youth of Tigray to their certain deaths in the name of taking back power from the state?

Selam/
Senior Member
Posts: 17010
Joined: 04 Aug 2018, 13:15

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Selam/ » 05 Oct 2024, 09:40

ኢሬቻ፣ ወያኔና ሻዕቢያ ባዕድ አምልኮዎች ናቸው።

ኢትዮጵያ የሚለውን ስም በአፋቸው ይጠሩት ይሆናል እንጂ፣ መለኮታዊው ስም ልባቸውን እንደጦር ይወጋቸዋል። አረንጓዴ፣ ቢጫ፣ ቀይ ሲያዩ ልክፍታቸው ይነሳባቸዋል ያጥወለውላቸዋል።

ኢትዮጵያን የጠላ የተረገመ ይሁን።



Dama
Member+
Posts: 6436
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: መስቀል (ዳመራ) ና ኢሬቻ አከባበር በፊንፊኔ ስነፃፀሩ

Post by Dama » 05 Oct 2024, 11:09

Dinbitu
The historical progression of belief systems have been from worshiping multiple pagan gods to one Star god. From One Star god to one God as preached by its Prophets. And finally, Atheism. You're taking history back in reverse, back to where humanity started.

Post Reply