Ethiopian News, Current Affairs and Opinion Forum
Horus
Senior Member+
Posts: 35606
Joined: 19 Oct 2013, 19:34

ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Horus » 29 Apr 2025, 14:46

IT IS ABOUT TIME THAT PEOPLE ARE TALKING SOME SENSE!


Horus
Senior Member+
Posts: 35606
Joined: 19 Oct 2013, 19:34

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Horus » 29 Apr 2025, 14:58

MOST CRIMES IN ADDIS ARE COMMITTED BY ERITREANS


Zack
Senior Member
Posts: 16836
Joined: 17 Feb 2013, 08:24

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Zack » 29 Apr 2025, 16:07

It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich

Abere
Senior Member
Posts: 13622
Joined: 18 Jul 2019, 20:52

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Abere » 29 Apr 2025, 16:26

Zyeneba,

It is bad news for Eritrea, actually. Making null and void the signature of Meles Zenawi of Eritrea by Ethiopia is a step in the right direction. First, rescinding is an excellent measure. Ethiopia should, in fact, effectively call Eritrea as its province.
The UN is an NGO (a voluntary association) it does not decide on the existential threat of any country - the so-called fake independence and recognition is not an immutable natural law - it can be ripped either by bullet or consent -period. The proof is abundant, see Russia, heard of Canada, Pana, Greenland, etc. Ethiopia has the best reason; not only the best reason, but the best capacity to take over Assab just in 3 days. UN will never be there to fight. What did the NGO /UN gone when Crimea taken back and Gaza turned into demolition site. Only powerless 3rd world thugs cannot stop talking about UN.

I will be happy to witness that Meles Zenawi sh!t is torn apart. It is going to happen

Fed_Up
Senior Member+
Posts: 22728
Joined: 15 Apr 2009, 10:50

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Fed_Up » 29 Apr 2025, 16:34

Abere wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:26


አዎን ሰማንህ ሰገጤው ....ቀላል አናፋህ :roll:

Odie
Member
Posts: 3802
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Odie » 29 Apr 2025, 16:59

Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich

"It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law"

Check with AI, I tried same concept in the past. It is not that dead issue with current cut throat scenario and dog eat dog fight. There may be international heat but it is not a dead thing specially with status quo of Eritrea and bad international relation with interest groups. However, would not be easy to the Oromo-anarchists either as their international diplomacy is moribund unless there is some power encouraging them to do the potentially dangerous act! Doubt they will dare due to their home mess. If they dare, for sure HoA may see changes sooner or later :lol:

Dama
Member
Posts: 4272
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Dama » 29 Apr 2025, 17:17

Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich
Very well illustrated bad faith and conspiracy between EPLF and TPLF against Ethiopia to establish the referendum, execute the tlrefetendum and accept the result of the referendum. But, you erred in concluding that legal documents signed in bad faith are binding. No. Contracts signed in bad faith are not binding when it is discovered that there existed bad faith such as cheating, conspiracy, misrepresentations, short cuts and improper processes were used to achieve signing of the referendum.
Go easy on Gurage. Stop being racist.
Last edited by Dama on 29 Apr 2025, 17:23, edited 2 times in total.

Zack
Senior Member
Posts: 16836
Joined: 17 Feb 2013, 08:24

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Zack » 29 Apr 2025, 17:19

Yeah u go trust artificial so called software hahah
International law works only one way and that’s how I explained before. How bad Eritrea is or a banana republic sovereignty recognition is done only once . There is a difference between recognition of a state and recognition of a government for example Libya has two different government one recognised by the international community and the other one not . Somalia also has two governments actually 3 if we add Somaliland . But only government is recognised by the international community and that is the federal government. Alshabaab government and Somaliland government isn’t recognised . Same with Sudan one is recognised and one is not recognised. Same as yemen president hadi government is recognised the houthis are not .

But the recognition of a state is different it’s given and it remains unless the country it’s self relinquishes it’s claim to sovrreignty and willingly joins another country this is a possibility but I don’t see that happening either no country ever done that ever so.


Dr Zackovich

Zack
Senior Member
Posts: 16836
Joined: 17 Feb 2013, 08:24

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Zack » 29 Apr 2025, 17:34

Dama wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:17
Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich
Very well illustrated bad faith and conspiracy between EPLF and TPLF against Ethiopia to establish the referendum, execute the tlrefetendum and accept the result of the referendum. But, you erred in concluding that legal documents signed in bad faith are binding. No. Contracts signed in bad faith are not binding when it is discovered that there existed bad faith such as cheating, conspiracy, misrepresentations, short cuts and improper processes were used to achieve signing of the referendum.
Go easy on Gurage. Stop being racist.

On the contrary there is no law that says you can’t strong arm a country or government to fulfil ur demands as long as it is done legally the EPRDF was the recognised entity after the cold war Ethiopia the international community the west the rest of the world doesn’t see it in another way .this government that signed the independence referendum of Eritrea . Reigned over Ethiopia for the next 3 decades . It ruled all part of Ethiopia it was a legitimate government of Ethiopia it conducted relations with the international community it was the darling of the west matter in fact the international community welcomed the break through of Eritrea and Ethiopia peace deal which led to the independence and recognition of Eritrea in order to find peace . Had Eritrea unilaterally declared independence with out the consent of meles and sibhat . It would be the in the same predicament today as Somaliland is . The USA and the European countries wouldn’t recognise Eritrea if it didn’t conduct relations with the parent state Ethiopia. Somalilanders would bring the argument that somalia isn’t somaliland parent state because it was part of a country called the Somali republic but this is a flawed argument Somalia is viewed as one country and that Somalia and Somaliland were part of a union called the Somali republic . But the Somali republic kept on existing and unilateral secession isn’t condoned by the international community that’s why the international community refused to recognise Somaliland . So in a sense the Eritreans outsmarted their foes and got their country. It doesn’t matter how you do it . What matters is that you do it through the proper channels and that is what they did indeed.


Dr Zackovich

Odie
Member
Posts: 3802
Joined: 24 Jun 2024, 23:07

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Odie » 29 Apr 2025, 17:56

Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:34
Dama wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:17
Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich
Very well illustrated bad faith and conspiracy between EPLF and TPLF against Ethiopia to establish the referendum, execute the tlrefetendum and accept the result of the referendum. But, you erred in concluding that legal documents signed in bad faith are binding. No. Contracts signed in bad faith are not binding when it is discovered that there existed bad faith such as cheating, conspiracy, misrepresentations, short cuts and improper processes were used to achieve signing of the referendum.
Go easy on Gurage. Stop being racist.

On the contrary there is no law that says you can’t strong arm a country or government to fulfil ur demands as long as it is done legally the EPRDF was the recognised entity after the cold war Ethiopia the international community the west the rest of the world doesn’t see it in another way .this government that signed the independence referendum of Eritrea . Reigned over Ethiopia for the next 3 decades . It ruled all part of Ethiopia it was a legitimate government of Ethiopia it conducted relations with the international community it was the darling of the west matter in fact the international community welcomed the break through of Eritrea and Ethiopia peace deal which led to the independence and recognition of Eritrea in order to find peace . Had Eritrea unilaterally declared independence with out the consent of meles and sibhat . It would be the in the same predicament today as Somaliland is . The USA and the European countries wouldn’t recognise Eritrea if it didn’t conduct relations with the parent state Ethiopia. Somalilanders would bring the argument that somalia isn’t somaliland parent state because it was part of a country called the Somali republic but this is a flawed argument Somalia is viewed as one country and that Somalia and Somaliland were part of a union called the Somali republic . But the Somali republic kept on existing and unilateral secession isn’t condoned by the international community that’s why the international community refused to recognise Somaliland . So in a sense the Eritreans outsmarted their foes and got their country. It doesn’t matter how you do it . What matters is that you do it through the proper channels and that is what they did indeed.


Dr Zackovich
"Yeah u go trust artificial so called software hahah"

The AI looks at a lot of documents in seconds and synthesizes quite good information of course based on what you ask it. I don't think it is something you can shun like that but at your own risk. I am not really encouraging to do anything or being actively involved in the issue, but I just wanted to give you a heads up. You appear to give conclusions by assumption without looking at precedents. Situations have changed and the world order is not the same as few years back. It is just you need a strong backer with rich experience of what has happened in the region in the past 30 years, virtually HoA degenerating into chaos instead of peace and prosperity. If international interest groups or stake holders are into it, the systems both in Eritrea and Ethiopia need a radical change specially if that can happen without conflagrating the region :mrgreen:

Dama
Member
Posts: 4272
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Dama » 29 Apr 2025, 19:44

Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:34
Dama wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:17
Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich
Very well illustrated bad faith and conspiracy between EPLF and TPLF against Ethiopia to establish the referendum, execute the tlrefetendum and accept the result of the referendum. But, you erred in concluding that legal documents signed in bad faith are binding. No. Contracts signed in bad faith are not binding when it is discovered that there existed bad faith such as cheating, conspiracy, misrepresentations, short cuts and improper processes were used to achieve signing of the referendum.
Go easy on Gurage. Stop being racist.

On the contrary there is no law that says you can’t strong arm a country or government to fulfil ur demands as long as it is done legally the EPRDF was the recognised entity after the cold war Ethiopia the international community the west the rest of the world doesn’t see it in another way .this government that signed the independence referendum of Eritrea . Reigned over Ethiopia for the next 3 decades . It ruled all part of Ethiopia it was a legitimate government of Ethiopia it conducted relations with the international community it was the darling of the west matter in fact the international community welcomed the break through of Eritrea and Ethiopia peace deal which led to the independence and recognition of Eritrea in order to find peace . Had Eritrea unilaterally declared independence with out the consent of meles and sibhat . It would be the in the same predicament today as Somaliland is . The USA and the European countries wouldn’t recognise Eritrea if it didn’t conduct relations with the parent state Ethiopia. Somalilanders would bring the argument that somalia isn’t somaliland parent state because it was part of a country called the Somali republic but this is a flawed argument Somalia is viewed as one country and that Somalia and Somaliland were part of a union called the Somali republic . But the Somali republic kept on existing and unilateral secession isn’t condoned by the international community that’s why the international community refused to recognise Somaliland . So in a sense the Eritreans outsmarted their foes and got their country. It doesn’t matter how you do it . What matters is that you do it through the proper channels and that is what they did indeed.


Dr Zackovich
Disaggreable conclusion. Commonsense says if you cheated, tricked, rigged processes, jumped courses, or taken short cuts, ignored important processes for the sole purpose of achievinging signed contract, when these flaws are disocovered, the contract shall be null and void. Consult a law book or lawyer, they would exactly say this is so.
Bad faith signatures end their binding when their flawed processes are discovered. The cheating party is usually punished for punitive damages for knowingly corrupting the process of obtaining the contract signed.

Tiago
Member
Posts: 2624
Joined: 30 Jul 2018, 02:09

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Tiago » 29 Apr 2025, 20:06

Just when the people of Ethiopia dream of having a nation minus TPLF and all hateful and parasitic Tigres,some idiots want to include Eritrea as part of Ethiopia.
Both Eritrea and Tigrai are one and the same mfing backstabbing,hateful, pretentious,I-know-it-all curse on Ethiopians.
In fact,it is wise to expel the chigaram Tigres and force them to join their cousins /Eritreans/ or have their own banana republic .
Horus has nothing to fear not even GOD.

Selam/
Senior Member
Posts: 15033
Joined: 04 Aug 2018, 13:15

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Selam/ » 29 Apr 2025, 20:16

ሙልጭልጭ ጭልፊቱ
ኢሱ ብብት ስር ሲተሻሽ የነበረው ፈሳሙ ዓብዮትህ፣ ልክ እንደ ትህነግና ሸኔ፣ ከኤርትራ ክፍለ ሃገርም ጋር ዕርቅ ፈጥረናል ብሎ ሲያውጅ፣ ዛሬ የተናገርከውን ረስተህ፣ እጥፍ ብለህ እንደለመድከው እንደምታሽቃብጥለት የታወቀ ነው። ፈስ!

Dama
Member
Posts: 4272
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Dama » 29 Apr 2025, 20:33

Dr.Zack

If we agree on the law of bad faith contracts end their usefulness or binding when it is discoveted that they were obtained by fraud, we can then go to discuss how Ethiopia was cheated, defrauded of its interests, and how Ethiopia could be made whole.

Horus
Senior Member+
Posts: 35606
Joined: 19 Oct 2013, 19:34

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Horus » 29 Apr 2025, 20:46

Zack,
First, I like your candor. The Ethiopian people were never given the opportunity to express their consent in the matter. TPLF/EPLF dominated "parliament" decided on the fate a nation of 130 million. Now, surely PP dominated "parliament" will revoke that decision. But notice, the current Ethiopia government has a much robust nation political support for the revocation. That is the first step as Abere Said.

What is is important is not the legal fictions regarding UN, AU, IGAD etc. The central significance of the revocation concerns the relationship on the ground between Ethiopia and Eritrea and the connected Horn countries. This will change all the games. Border issues, questions of rights and sovereignty, movement of peoples and any and all matters of legality. The pandora box is open for eternity.

Ethiopia considering Eritrea as one of its historical provinces will take us back to the Status quo ante! Then all bets will be up for play.

አልጠግብ ባይ ሲተፋ ያድራል ነውና ይቺ short sighted, illegal and እብሪተኛ moves of Meles, Sibhat Nega and Isayas will come home to roost!

Follow the unfolding drama!

tarik
Senior Member+
Posts: 35299
Joined: 26 Feb 2016, 13:04

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by tarik » 29 Apr 2025, 20:55

Hey fake pharoah Horus, i have changed your name to 2 legged galla abiy's slave horse. Not you or your useless and toothless aid addicted dead ethiopia or your dead galla-abiy can talk about my Eritrea's recognition, who z fkkkkk do you think you are. The world knows your aid addicted ethiopia thanks to micheal jackson's we r the world he begged the world 4 money 2 feed you and you still haven't not even fed yet, go and get lost you galla slave :lol:

. This is you useless galla slave horse.

Dama
Member
Posts: 4272
Joined: 22 Jun 2024, 21:05

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Dama » 29 Apr 2025, 22:07

Horus wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 20:46
Zack,
First, I like your candor. The Ethiopian people were never given the opportunity to express their consent in the matter. TPLF/EPLF dominated "parliament" decided on the fate a nation of 130 million. Now, surely PP dominated "parliament" will revoke that decision. But notice, the current Ethiopia government has a much robust nation political support for the revocation. That is the first step as Abere Said.

What is is important is not the legal fictions regarding UN, AU, IGAD etc. The central significance of the revocation concerns the relationship on the ground between Ethiopia and Eritrea and the connected Horn countries. This will change all the games. Border issues, questions of rights and sovereignty, movement of peoples and any and all matters of legality. The pandora box is open for eternity.

Ethiopia considering Eritrea as one of its historical provinces will take us back to the Status quo ante! Then all bets will be up for play.

አልጠግብ ባይ ሲተፋ ያድራል ነውና ይቺ short sighted, illegal and እብሪተኛ moves of Meles, Sibhat Nega and Isayas will come home to roost!

Follow the unfolding drama!
These situations, in themselves, are not cause for dishonoring the Eritrean independence. These are persussive, mitigating factors that can insinuate and hasten the process of legally revoking the Eritrean referendum.

Zack
Senior Member
Posts: 16836
Joined: 17 Feb 2013, 08:24

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Zack » 30 Apr 2025, 00:57

Dama wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 19:44
Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:34
Dama wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 17:17
Zack wrote:
29 Apr 2025, 16:07
It don’t matter it can’t be reversed according to international law Ethiopia can recall its ambassador to Eritrea and cut all ties with Eritrea . But Eritrea is an recognised nation member of the United Nations member of the African Union member of Igad. And observer member of the Arab league . International law doesn’t work according to the tribal laws of Ethiopia or the gurage tribal laws. When Eritrea was given an “United nation supervised referendum with the approval of Ethiopia. That was the moment it was done according to international law , Eritrea secession from Ethiopia was done in a legal manner . Ethiopia had one card had it denied Eritrea a supervised referendum in 1993 then Ethiopia would have had the upper hand but , Eritrea and EPLF rebels played it smart they put their cousins tigrayans in power in Addis Ababa they signed off on the referendum . I would even say that isias afewerki hold the pen of sibhat nega while he signed it , so this is a done deal it can’t be reversed now the damage has been done for Ethiopia at least . For Eritrea 1993 was joyful year . So you can’t reverse so what you could say is Ethiopia can cut ties with Eritrea it can even say a statement that it revoked the recognition of Eritrea but it won’t have any sort of impact , at all according to international law and that is international law my friend not gurage law dear lad . For example Kosovo is denied statehood by Serbia. Serbia doesn’t recognise Kosovo referendum it calls it illegal . It wasn’t even a United nation supervised referendum . Serbia stands firm from a legal point of view and has a legal argument that Kosovo is part of Serbia . The mother country doesn’t approve the secession of kosovo. It was ochostrated by the west as it seems.


Dr Zackovich
Very well illustrated bad faith and conspiracy between EPLF and TPLF against Ethiopia to establish the referendum, execute the tlrefetendum and accept the result of the referendum. But, you erred in concluding that legal documents signed in bad faith are binding. No. Contracts signed in bad faith are not binding when it is discovered that there existed bad faith such as cheating, conspiracy, misrepresentations, short cuts and improper processes were used to achieve signing of the referendum.
Go easy on Gurage. Stop being racist.

On the contrary there is no law that says you can’t strong arm a country or government to fulfil ur demands as long as it is done legally the EPRDF was the recognised entity after the cold war Ethiopia the international community the west the rest of the world doesn’t see it in another way .this government that signed the independence referendum of Eritrea . Reigned over Ethiopia for the next 3 decades . It ruled all part of Ethiopia it was a legitimate government of Ethiopia it conducted relations with the international community it was the darling of the west matter in fact the international community welcomed the break through of Eritrea and Ethiopia peace deal which led to the independence and recognition of Eritrea in order to find peace . Had Eritrea unilaterally declared independence with out the consent of meles and sibhat . It would be the in the same predicament today as Somaliland is . The USA and the European countries wouldn’t recognise Eritrea if it didn’t conduct relations with the parent state Ethiopia. Somalilanders would bring the argument that somalia isn’t somaliland parent state because it was part of a country called the Somali republic but this is a flawed argument Somalia is viewed as one country and that Somalia and Somaliland were part of a union called the Somali republic . But the Somali republic kept on existing and unilateral secession isn’t condoned by the international community that’s why the international community refused to recognise Somaliland . So in a sense the Eritreans outsmarted their foes and got their country. It doesn’t matter how you do it . What matters is that you do it through the proper channels and that is what they did indeed.


Dr Zackovich
Disaggreable conclusion. Commonsense says if you cheated, tricked, rigged processes, jumped courses, or taken short cuts, ignored important processes for the sole purpose of achievinging signed contract, when these flaws are disocovered, the contract shall be null and void. Consult a law book or lawyer, they would exactly say this is so.
Bad faith signatures end their binding when their flawed processes are discovered. The cheating party is usually punished for punitive damages for knowingly corrupting the process of obtaining the contract signed.



But there is no cheating no one forced the Ethiopian government to concede on the demands of Eritrea . The two held talks prior to the set up of the referendum came to the conclusion in order to end the war it’s only democracy that can give the Eritrean people a voice to issue their self determination. The international community welcomed this decision because its a mature way to handle And as they did the there was no coercion or any other sort of Mis conduct . Had the Ethiopian government said we were coerced bribed or any sort of evidence for that . Then it would open some sort of debate on the matter it was achieved but even that won’t be enough to conclude that the referendum was null and void because it was obtained in an illegal way . Actually no rebel movement or secessionist entity has ever obtained a referendum United Nations supervised referendum illegally it has never happend in history . It would be the first if it happend .
Besides for the Ethiopians. Why on earth would u want to force a people that do not consider u their countrymen why on earth would u force them to be part of ur country it will never work indeed

Dr Zackovich

Horus
Senior Member+
Posts: 35606
Joined: 19 Oct 2013, 19:34

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Horus » 30 Apr 2025, 01:34

Zack,
Nobody wanted to force you to be Ethiopia against your will. Now, the whole and entire issue is that Assab is an Ethiopian property that was illegally taken by means of conspiracy from a nation that has no advocate or a defender in a detrimental historic decision. Remember, the American mediator is still alive. He had specifically stated/demanded that Assab was an Ethiopian territory but the two brothers in arms took a free ride over the very existential interest of Ethiopia.

Zack, believe me that as long as there Ethiopia and an Ethiopian government of any kind, this issue will not go away.

Deqi-Arawit
Senior Member
Posts: 14823
Joined: 29 Mar 2009, 11:10
Location: Bujumbura Brundi

Re: ETHIOPIA WILL REVOKE ITS RECOGNITION OF ERITREA AS AN INDEPENDENT STATE

Post by Deqi-Arawit » 30 Apr 2025, 01:58

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

These Low IQ are amazing.

Any patriot leader who come after the junkie dictator who is ruling Eritrea with iron fist will recognize and encourage the implementation of article 39 in Ethiopia.

Post Reply