Page 1 of 1
Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 01:45
by Noble Amhara
they were arguing about halaba identity changing from gurage to hadiya.... you'd think hadiya is shankila just listening to them
Hadiya Lady
Gurage Lady
almost identical
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 01:56
by Horus
Noble Amhara wrote: ↑18 Jul 2024, 01:45
they were arguing about halaba identity changing from gurage to hadiya.... you'd think hadiya is shankila just listening to them
Hadiya Lady
Gurage Lady
almost identical
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 02:00
by Horus
Noble Amhara wrote: ↑18 Jul 2024, 01:45
they were arguing about halaba identity changing from gurage to hadiya.... you'd think hadiya is shankila just listening to them
Hadiya Lady
Gurage Lady
almost identical
Both songs are gospel Pente songs. Their rhythm comes from protestant church. The two languages are totally different. Hadiya is Hamitic language. Gurage speaks Semitic language.
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 03:58
by Odie
“they were arguing about halaba identity changing from gurage to hadiya.... you'd think hadiya is shankila just listening to them”
ማንነትህ የጠፋብህ ስውዬ በማታውቀው ነገር ገብተህ ትፈተፍታለህ::
ጉራጌ ጆሮውን ብቲዘው አንድ ህድይኛ ወይም ሲዳምኛ ወይም ከምባትኛ ወይም ወላይትኛ ቃል አይስማም :: በውዝዋዜ እንኳን የሚያንቀሳቅሱት አካላቸው አይገናኝም:: አንተ ልታመሳሰላቸው ትሞክራለህ:: ሁሉም በባህላቸው ኩሩ ኢትዮዽያውያን ናቸው:: ሁሉም ለዚች አገር ያላቸውን አበርክተዋል:: ይሄ shallow የብልፅግና እውቀተችሁ ይዛችሁ ነው ይህችን diverse and complex አገር ልትመሩ የምትሞክሩት like a monkey sitting trying to capture the drawing of the universe!
ይቺ ሁሌ የምትለጥፋት ይ genetic picture ይህን ነግሮሃል?
የፕሮቴስታንት መዝሙር አንዳንዶች ከእንግሊዝኛ ተገልብጠው ሲዘመሩ ቅላፄያቸው በየትኛውም ቋንቋ ተመሳሳይ ይመስላል ግን ቋንቋዎቹ አንድ ነው ማለት አይደለም:: ይህን ስምተህ እንዳይሆን?
እናንተ የዘር ፖለቲከኞች it looks all of you had your brain zapped the same way as you think the same way all the time. እናንተን የሚተካ ትውልድ እስኪፈጠር the country is doomed. የምእተ አመታት mess!!
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 04:47
by Noble Amhara
hold your horses
I said they look similar not the language but their look. So if Gurage means Guraginya tenagere bicha well that means you disqualify the Gurages of Waliso (Chebo) and the Hadiya of Arsi who today only speak oromo
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 18 Jul 2024, 07:31
by Odie
Noble Amhara wrote: ↑18 Jul 2024, 04:47
hold your horses
I said they look similar not the language but their look. So if Gurage means Guraginya tenagere bicha well that means you disqualify the Gurages of Waliso (Chebo) and the Hadiya of Arsi who today only speak oromo
Sir
They are swallowed people.
Hadya used to be its own kind of empire before Oromo expansion etc as you probably know. Gurage was a lot more than what it is before again Oromo rampage and gragn atrocities. However, what I am saying is nothing much in common with regard to language similarity among southerners. All of them are proud ethiopians with proud language & specific cultural identity. Don’t assume they have similarity because the certain way you think people produce sound.
I am not trying to be ethnic centered but whichever way the country goes, the identity of these people should be allowed to be expressed but not politicized the way the dumb TPLF/OPDO/OLF/PP stealing and killing political industrial complex.
I know I have added something you don’t want to hear again.
We are doing this stupid discussion because of the ethnic scourge the above bunch and ሻውያ introduced to the country. Otherwise you and me would be discussing some thing better like the global west. Now we are bickering in our so called 100 years homework!!
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 25 Mar 2026, 01:47
by TesfaNews
Odie wrote: ↑18 Jul 2024, 07:31
Noble Amhara wrote: ↑18 Jul 2024, 04:47
hold your horses
I said they look similar not the language but their look. So if Gurage means Guraginya tenagere bicha well that means you disqualify the Gurages of Waliso (Chebo) and the Hadiya of Arsi who today only speak oromo
Sir
They are swallowed people.
Hadya used to be its own kind of empire before Oromo expansion etc as you probably know. Gurage was a lot more than what it is before again Oromo rampage and gragn atrocities. However, what I am saying is nothing much in common with regard to language similarity among southerners. All of them are proud ethiopians with proud language & specific cultural identity. Don’t assume they have similarity because the certain way you think people produce sound.
I am not trying to be ethnic centered but whichever way the country goes, the identity of these people should be allowed to be expressed but not politicized the way the dumb TPLF/OPDO/OLF/PP stealing and killing political industrial complex.
I know I have added something you don’t want to hear again.
We are doing this stupid discussion because of the ethnic scourge the above bunch and ሻውያ introduced to the country. Otherwise you and me would be discussing some thing better like the global west. Now we are bickering in our so called 100 years homework!!
hadiya are cushitic gurage speak a semetic language with an agew accent meaning your orgin is Agaw!
Re: Horus and Dama said Gurage is unrelated to Hadiya
Posted: 25 Mar 2026, 21:13
by Dama
Odie, don't misunderstand Noble as did Whorus. Noble did not speak of Gurage and Hadiya language or music similarities.
He only talked about similarity of the looks of the two girls singing. He specifically said, Hadiya Lady and Gurage Lady.
But he misunderstood us about what we said Whorus and I sometime in the past. He was trying to prove his misunderstanding of us as if we said Gurage and Hadiya looked different. No we did not say that. Somewhere, sometime, Whorus and I said that Halaba was a semitic group like Silte but now speaks Highland East Cushitic language, similar to Hadiya, Kembata and Sidama. They however retained their semtic dance style exactly like Silte's and Welene.
In Gurage folklore, the Inequamt subclan of Chaha that inhabits East Chaha or Anget Chaha region called Gwemare or Gumer from which Mahmud Ahmed and Hailu Fereja hail from are said to have splintered fron Halaba and settled in Gumer region of Chaha on border with Silte. They speak the Chaha dialect. Inekuamts are found anywhere and everywhere in every corner of Chaha, but their predominant location is Gwemare or West Chaha or Anget Chaha. Hailu Fereja is the husband of the gifted artist Yitagesu Meles.
Qasa Qasa: Hailu Fereja
Qasa qasa means searching for someone or something desperately, nervously, incessantly.
Yetenbi by Yitagesu Meles