Page 1 of 1

Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 01 Mar 2024, 21:44
by Axumezana
- King of Kings Yohannes restructured Ethiopia under Confederate/ Federal arrangement and allowed kings to rule their respective regions and build their own respective army

- He unified the then Ethiopia under three kings( King Teklehaimanot of Gojam, King Michael of Wello, and King Minilik of Shoua, and gave King Minilik and King to Teklehaimanot the directive to expand their respective territories to South , West and East which ultimately resulted in the present day Ethiopia( with more additions during King Haile Selassie time).

- Though King Minilik worked to dismantle the Confederated/ Federated Ethiopia after he became the King of Ethiopia፣ to form a Unitary Ethiopia he benefited from the armies that were created during Emperor Yohannes governance system and also additional manpower and resources he gained by the directive he was given by Emperor Yohannes to expand.
However,
- Ethiopia was unable to defend itself during the second invasion of Ethiopia in the early 20th Century due to the unified structure Minilik established and further reinforced by King Haile Selassie , that abolished regional kings and concentrated all military power around one king.

Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 01 Mar 2024, 22:54
by Halafi Mengedi
I understand your stand or view, no problem about it but there was no link what you stated. When King Yohannes was alive there was no confederacies or federalist military system in Ethiopia, yes there was Kililization by ethnics started to shape up before prematurely the king death but never fully implemented. Militarily there was no centralized military command, every region had their own, even in Tigray the same and even in Tembien the lords aka Raesi had their own and when they join for war every Raesi pick their spot and fight with their own leader or Raesi. Unlike the old system during king Yohannes, TPLF had centralized military command and all mingled all over Tigray controlled by the central command Seye was the leader for the military command and the Ganta Haili take orders from the central command and implement them at the ground against enemies. TDF is the something central command and where ever they fought like TPLF, all Tigrayans are the battle participants, no region of Tigray fought harder than any other because TPLF or TDF are from all Tigray walk of life.

Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 02 Mar 2024, 00:11
by Axumezana
Greetings Halafi Mengedi,

Emperor Yohannes was the only Kings of Kings in Ethiopia after the collapse of the Axumite empire. As I mentioned it in my post , Emperor Yohannes structured the territories and governance of Ethiopia under four Kings . One direct under himself that includes Tigray( including Eritrea) Gondar & Afar , King Teklehaimanot for Gojam, King Michael for Wello, and King Minilik for Shoua. The three Kings were empowered to run their regions independently , creating formal communication with other countries, build their own military power and expand thier respective territories . This arrangement is more Confederalist than Federalist. All three were paying tributes to the King of Kings and he was also directing them to go to war to defend Ethiopia. Tigrayanism only will survive by balancing unity and diversity! The more Tigrayans focus on their differences the more they will be weak and manipulated by their enemies. Axumezana's vision is for creating of united and democratic Tigray which accommodates " Unity in diversity ". Same is also true for Ethiopia. Ultimately my life time vision is to work toward a confederated/ Federated Ethiopia centered in Tigray Axum. May be that vision will be realized the next 20 to 30 years! Looking forward to get your feedback on the above!

Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 02 Mar 2024, 00:34
by Halafi Mengedi
Greeting Axumzena,

The king of kings was to assign kings to each ethnic and rival provinces and he started by handing king of Shewa and Gojjam only but had the king lived longer he could have given to all ethnics the way TPLF followed up his principle and gave all ethnics their kilil to administer with their chosen language and culture and still exists but there was no a single military central command in that country during Tewodros or Yohannes, even in 1935 when the Italian came back, in Tigray there was no central command, Tembien had its own in Worka Eba garrison, Agame had its own garrison in Agame, Shire had its own garrison in Shire, Enderta had its own garisson in Enderta, Raya had its own garrison in Raya with few King Haileselassie trained special forces then Dessie had Amhara garrison. The Hamassien Italian soldiers advised the Italians to march straight to Temgien garrison with all force and if you win Tembien you are in Addis Ababa within a week and the Italians did that and they crashed Tembien and went to Enderta did not last for hours, the same Raya and Dessie and reached Addis Ababa with out much challenge. The Agame and Shire garrison fallen apart without fight when they heard the Tembien forces were beaten.




Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 02 Mar 2024, 00:48
by Axumezana
Halafi Mengedi,

I agree with you there was no unified military under one command and that was the reason King Minilik was able to exploit to betray King of Kings Yohannes. With regard to the various garrisons in Tigray, I do not have the knowledge and I appreciate sending me reference books/ publications to educate myself. Of course I know that each district's leader( መስፍን) had their own informal military unit recruited from farmers under their respective administration.

Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 02 Mar 2024, 02:12
by Halafi Mengedi
Axumezana wrote:
02 Mar 2024, 00:48
Halafi Mengedi,

I agree with you there was no unified military under one command and that was the reason King Minilik was able to exploit to betray King of Kings Yohannes. With regard to the various garrisons in Tigray, I do not have the knowledge and I appreciate sending me reference books/ publications to educate myself. Of course I know that each district's leader( መስፍን) had their own informal military unit recruited from farmers under their respective administration.
It is in google you can find it written in English. That Italian video almost band in Tigray not to be seen because the Adwans were in the Italians payroll in Asmara before they marched to Tembien garrison and how they fought the garrison you can see it yourself the true story Adwans do not want to show the rest of Tigray. Adwa landscape is better than Tembien for guerrilla war yet the Italians were marching to Tembien crossing the entire Adwa without any incident like merchants going to Tembien market place, but as soon as they crossed Maiqnetal the border between Adwa and Tembien called "Wor'ee" forest used to be and the bombardment started from the ground with heavy weapons and from the air raining as you see the video. The video is how the Hamassien and Seraye soldiers with Italians marched to Tembien with the Italians and advised them to march to Tembien garrison and used chemical weapons too in that video and others we have not seen them but I was told. BTW, my own father as a young mad commanded his unit and was there in that war video Wor'ee Worgamba and Worsege the other video 10,888 Italian soldier, commanders and generals identified and buried in that video one spot.

Re: Military built due to Yohannes's Confederalist/ Federalist system was the main reason for the victory of Adawa!

Posted: 02 Mar 2024, 02:50
by Axumezana
I promise to study this subject !

During the 2nd war of Italy, Tigray was marginalized, divided and poor, perhaps Tembien could had been stronger during that time. Let us work together so that we will be able to build a strong Tigray that could be the center of gravity of the Horn Africa. Halafi democratic "Unity In Diversity " is the way forward for Tigray and Ethiopia!