Fikre
The First Casualty: Truth
Dr. Fikrejesus Amhazion
https://fiqre4eri.wordpress.com/2020/11 ... ssion=true
6 hours ago
Several days ago, I suggested that we all remain cautious of the considerable amount of disinformation, misinformation, misguided comments, and sloppy or poor journalism swirling around as things rapidly unfold in Ethiopia. Again, spreading rumors or false information, sharing fake news, and making grandiose or major claims without evidence is not only highly irresponsible in this case (or any other, for that matter), it is extremely dangerous and can have truly fatal consequences. Restraint and patience should be exercised, now more than ever, as this is a situation that is already tense and does not need further inflaming.
In the days following my post, a large number of examples of what I cautioned people to be wary of have arisen.
Among the particularly “
amusing” ones was the following
The other rebel group in the EPRDF coalition was the Eritrean People’s Liberation Front (EPLF) led by Isaias Afwerki. In 1993 it broke away and established an independent Eritrea. Five years later it waged most idiotic war over worthless border property at Badme.
There a lot of errors there to unpack, but focusing just on the EPRDF claim, although a relatively small and minor “
error”, it does reflect the inadequacies and shortcomings of many of the comments and analyses being spread at the moment. If so-called experts are lackadaisical with such details, what does it imply and suggest about their understanding of the larger, vastly more complex issues unfolding? (Amazingly, when offered a correction, the expert author of the above quote chose to double-down
which reveals quite a lot.)
Additionally, it is mind-boggling how some are “
reporting”, without credible evidence, that a country they have long (and recently) described as weak, empty, in terminal crisis and total disarray, and the epitome of a “
failed state”, is actually masterminding everything unfolding across the Horn as it slowly and craftily implements its secret plans for a grand regional empire. How is it possible, one may legitimately ask, that a country we are regularly told cannot even adequately govern its small population and is completely unable of administrating or controlling its various external regions or borders, is busy dictating things and redrawing lines across the Horn of Africa?
Increasingly, there is also a steady stream of contradictory, back-and-forth reports and “
informed” updates, sternly warning Eritrea
not to intervene or interfere,
but at the same time stating that it is actually engaged in heavy and fierce fighting along on its border.
The simple fact is that Eritrea’s current fighting engagements are restricted to COVID-19 and desert locusts. It is not rushing troops across its borders or engaged in the present fighting, in Badme or elsewhere. The historical record also clearly shows how for several decades it has persistently called for the international community to perform its moral and legal duties, even when it has been on the receiving end of unprovoked attacks.
An interesting question however is, even if it was fighting (which it isn’t at present), could it accurately and appropriately be described as “
intervening or interfering” to attend to large-scale activities that are unfolding on territories that the international community has declared as Eritrean? Could the country be legitimately blamed or criticized? (Note that in the eyes of so-called experts its failure to do so would actually make it a weak, failed state.)
Of course, as I noted several days ago
https://fiqre4eri.wordpress.com/2020/11 ... nt-events/, it is also highly interesting that so many of those now claiming that Eritrea is intervening and stationing forces in neighboring lands, were actually totally silent (or actually supportive) as large swathes of its territories remained under an illegal foreign military occupation and as it suffered numerous provocations and withstood unrelenting aggression. Where were the calls for non-intervention or removal of military and security forces stationed on foreign lands then? Since intervention is so terrible, shouldn’t it always be condemned and rejected?
We also all should be in total awe of the amazing imagery and portrayals being presented – true masterpieces – that the TPLF is somehow an innocent victim here, that it is a “
force for good”, that it is genuinely committed to peace and dialogue, and that it is being “
attacked” because it chose to defend democracy and protect rights. This is dishonest or deluded. Nothing could be further from the truth. The indelible facts are that the TPLF ignited the latest developments. It is the TPLF that has been preparing for war, stockpiling weapons, and training militias for years (using funds that were actually to be for Tigray’s people and development). And it is the TPLF that has been the obstacle to peace and the central cause of so much of the tension, violence, and instability that have unfolded over the past several months and years. The misguided images and portrayals are also a sharp, bitter insult to the many, many people across the vast expanse of the Horn of Africa who have been the unfortunate recipients of the TPLF’s so-called deep and genuine commitment to democracy, peace, and dialogue.
Finally, it is very unfortunate and disappointing, although not at all surprising based on historical precedent, that the statements and claims from some in the region, no matter their alignment with reality, are not merely to be assumed false but are totally dismissed, rejected, and ignored. It seems that only assertions from officials from the noble, democratic, and peace-loving TPLF (and its supporters), with its proud, well-earned reputation for honesty, transparency, truth, and integrity, are to be considered as objective truth and disseminated uncritically.