Skip to main content
User account menu
Register
Support Us
Log In
Search
Search
Search
Home Small Wars Journal
AMID RED SEA RIVALRIES, ERITREA PLAYS FOR INDEPENDENCE
Articles
Amid Red Sea Rivalries, Eritrea Plays for Independence
President Isaias proposes a regional bloc to balance the rising influence of Gulf states.
Harry Verhoeven
When Eritrea’s president last month hosted the leaders of Ethiopia and Somalia to discuss “regional cooperation,” that initiative drew few global headlines. Still, Eritrea’s move should be noted by policymakers and others working for stability in the Horn of Africa and the Red Sea region. For years, President Isaias Afwerki’s disdain for multilateral forums such as the African Union, and his strained relations with many governments in the region, have contributed to caricatures of Eritrea as the “North Korea of Africa.” But his invitation for two neighbors to discuss a new regional bloc reflects an important factor in Eritrea’s foreign policy: its efforts to preserve its independence in a fast-evolving geopolitical environment.
Effectively, Isaias’ proposal is a fine-tuning of Eritrea’s alignments amid the growing influence of Arab Gulf states in Africa and consistent with long-standing efforts to preserve its independence, notes Professor Harry Verhoeven, convenor of the Oxford University China-Africa Network.
Eritrea evolved a reputation as perhaps Africa’s most isolated state. Hasn’t it historically been hostile to regional integration?
Yes and no. Eritrea’s relationship with the idea of regional cooperation has been complex ever since the country gained its independence from Ethiopia in 1993 following a 30-year war. That same year, Eritrean President Isaias Afewerki stunned his African peers when, at a summit of the Organization of African Unity (now the African Union), he publicly repeated criticisms he had formulated as one of Africa’s most formidable guerrilla commanders: the OAU had utterly failed by closing its eyes to the terror inflicted by Ethiopia’s Soviet-backed military dictatorship (the Derg) and he accused his peers of clinging to power while failing to take any meaningful action to address poverty in Africa. From that starting point, Eritrea never invested significant resources in continent-wide diplomacy. When the African Union (AU) imposed sanctions on Eritrea in 2009 for supporting al-Shabab extremists in Somalia and seeking to overthrow the Somali government, Eritrea suspended its participation in the organization and denounced the AU as a lapdog of U.S. imperialism and a mechanism for the hegemonic aspirations of Ethiopia, its main rival. In addition, Eritrea has twice withdrawn from the East African regional bloc—the Intergovernmental Authority on Development (IGAD).
Still, Eritrea is not by definition opposed to regional cooperation. In the 1990s, Isaias and his fighters formed the vanguard of the wave of leftist African liberation movements that captured power from the Red Sea to the Cape between 1991 and 1997. Together with “comrade-leaders” in Congo, Ethiopia, Rwanda and Uganda, Isaias dreamed of a “Greater Horn of Africa” of like-minded regimes who could offer an alternative to the much-criticized OAU and jointly develop regional investment opportunities to cement ideological solidarity. The government in Asmara sent Eritrean troops, spies and diplomats to support wars against the military-Islamist regime in Sudan and the dictatorship of Mobutu Seso Seko in the Democratic Republic of Congo (then Zaire). These were concrete sacrifices in blood and treasure made by a fragile, small and newly independent Eritrea to further its preferred form of regional integration.
What might Isaias hope to achieve with this new initiative?
Isaias’ proposal to deepen integration between Eritrea, Ethiopia and Somalia (the so-called "Cushitic Alliance") is a continuation of efforts he championed in the 1990s to institutionally anchor alliances between governments with a similar political outlook. Just like in the era of the “Greater Horn,” Asmara appears to be proposing new regional norms and understandings of peace and security as well as infrastructure ties to forge a web of partnerships among the participating states.
This said, the disappointments of the past have not been forgotten—most particularly not since the 1998-2000 “war of brothers” with Ethiopia, which ended the dream of the “Greater Horn.” Eritrean diplomacy, especially since that conflict, has been focused on creating space to maneuver and chart a foreign policy independent of Ethiopian hegemony. For almost 20 years, Isaias sought to undermine the Ethiopian government by supporting its domestic opposition as well as its adversaries in Somalia—policies that contributed to the imposition of international sanctions. Eritrea also aligned itself with Ethiopia’s rival, Egypt, and by establishing partnerships with Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates in which Isaias offered security cooperation—notably the use of Eritrea’s Red Sea port of Assab for operations in the Yemen war—in exchange for economic support against Ethiopian pressures. While this diplomatic choreography failed to stop Ethiopia’s regional ascendancy, it achieved the chief objective of keeping Isaias’ government in power.
Last month’s summit signals a change in the pattern of Isaias’ maneuvering, caused by recent geopolitical shifts. The Gulf states’ projection of power in the Horn of Africa and the European refugee crisis have provided Isaias with diplomatic and financial leverage to move from isolation to regional influence. In addition, the ascension of Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed side-lined Isaias’ Ethiopian nemesis, the Tigrayan People’s Liberation Front. That made it possible for Isaias to cooperate with Abiy in quickly negotiating an end to their countries’ “frozen” war. While that peace accord was a domestic popular triumph for both leaders, the rapprochement has stalled and the hoped-for “peace dividends”—economic and democratic—have been disappointing. The rise of the younger Abiy in Addis Ababa has allowed Isaias to pose as the region’s elder statesman and—in last month’s summit conference—to proffer his own idea for cooperation in the Horn of Africa; Isaias’ proposal will in fact undercut Ethiopia’s historic ambitions to once again dominate efforts toward greater regional integration.
Other players are moving to establish regional organizations in the Red Sea area, as Saudi Arabia just did in January. What are the implications of the Eritrean initiative in light of those efforts?
Recent efforts to establish new regional bodies, such as the Council of the Arab and African States of the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden, or to reinvigorate IGAD or the AU in the Horn of Africa, are ambivalent developments from Eritrea’s perspective. Its priority remains the preservation of its flexibility to shift policies and alignments as necessary to defend its independence, squeezed as it is among larger neighbors. Sudan, Ethiopia and Saudi Arabia have all had their own designs for the region, which have rarely accounted for Eritrean interests. As seen from Asmara, multilateral organizations under the control of actors with hegemonic ambitions are therefore potentially dangerous and better subverted or, if need be, boycotted altogether.
Eritrea joined the Red Sea Council at Riyadh’s unrelenting insistence but likely has no intention of letting the body circumscribe its sovereignty. Membership served the useful purpose of confirming the Saudi-Eritrea relationship and of reminding Ethiopia (which, at the insistence of Egypt, was not invited to join the council) that, despite the outward expressions of fraternity between Abiy and Isaias, Eritrea has strategic options that do not require Ethiopia’s consent.
Similarly, Isaias’ move toward a new grouping with Ethiopia and Somalia is useful to remind old foes in the Horn of Africa (Djibouti and Sudan) and the Gulf states that Eritrea has alternative friends and will not accept a role as regional proxy for Saudi Arabia or the United Arab Emirates. The growing projection of the Gulf states’ power in the Horn helped Isaias to break out of his isolation. But from the Eritrean perspective, that projection is a trend that requires careful management, rather than further encouragement, and that needs to be assessed in terms of its implications for Eritrea’s autonomy going forward.
This article is cross-posted here with permission (on agreement) from the United States Institute of Peace.
Categories: Middle East - Africa
Log in or register to post comments
About the Author(s)
Harry Verhoeven
Dr. Harry Verhoeven is the convenor of the Oxford University China-Africa Network.
RECENT HEADLINES
Iran or Allies Are Plotting Against US Forces, U.S. Intelligence Suggests by WSJ
Fractures Grow Among Iraq Militias, Spell Political Retreat by Reuters
Italy’s Coronavirus Death Toll Is Far Higher Than Reported by WSJ
Covid-19 is Killing Off Our Traditional Notions of National Defense by WaPo
Military Memo from 2017 Warned of Pandemic’s Impact on Combat Readiness and Risk of War by Military Times
Prepare for War or Fight Coronavirus? US Military Battles Competing Instincts by NYT
Coronavirus: Iran's Official Death Toll Passes 3,000 by BBC News
Trump: US to Deploy Anti-Drug Navy Ships Near Venezuela by AP
Iran Says US Sanctions Are Taking Lives. US Officials Disagree. by NYT
Port of LA Engineer Intentionally Derailed Train in Attempted Attack on USNS Mercy, Federal Prosecutors Say by KTLA5
Protective Gear in National Stockpile Nearly Depleted, DHS Officials Say by WaPo
Hospitals, Doctors Feel Financial Squeeze of Coronavirus Crisis by WSJ
Afghanistan and Taliban Begin Direct Talks With Aim of Prisoner Swap by BBC News
Air Force Academy Eases Coronavirus Lockdown After Two Cadets Die by Apparent Suicide by WaPo
New York Governor Says State Could See 16,000 Coronavirus Deaths by VOA News
COVID-19 Cases Among Veterans in New Orleans, New York Continue Steep Rise by Military Times
Coronavirus: Spain's Deaths Pass 9,000 as Infection Rate Slows by BBC News
China Releases Data on Asymptomatic Coronavirus Cases by VOA News
540 Additional Troops to Deploy to US-Mexico Border Over COVID-19 Concerns by Military Times
NATO Chief: Pandemic Won't Hamper Alliance's Capabilities by VOA News
Panel Wants to Double Federal Spending on AI by C4ISRNET
Navy to Evacuate 2,700 Sailors From Carrier Over ‘Next Couple Days’ Amid COVID-19 Pandemic by Navy Times
With COVID-19 threat to increase, Air Force Takes Steps to Protect its Most Important Missions by Defense News
Afghan Government, Taliban Team Discuss Prisoner Swap In Kabul by RFE/RL
Top Marine ‘Signaling’ to Industry that F-35 Cuts are On the Table by Defense News
Bolsonaro, Isolated and Defiant, Dismisses Coronavirus Threat to Brazil by NYT
US Navy Does Not Rule Out Punishing Captain of Carrier Who Blasted Coronavirus Response by Reuters
Trump Warns Iran Of 'Heavy Price' If US Attacked In Iraq by RFE/RL
Italy’s Coronavirus Death Toll Is Far Higher Than Reported by WSJ
Latest Guard Update: 17,250 Troops Mobilized for COVID-19 Response, 10 States, 2 Territories and DC on Title 32 Status by Military Times
Coronavirus Aid Coming 'From Russia With Love' - Or An Agenda? by RFE/RL
Spain Confirms 100,000 Coronavirus Cases; US Braces for Huge Death Toll by VOA News
Semper Modify: Marine Corps to Undergo 'Radical' Overhaul in Pivot to Take on China by Washington Times
Navy to Evacuate Thousands of Sailors From Carrier Theodore Roosevelt Amid COVID-19 Pandemic by Navy Times
US Governors Protest Shortage of Medical Equipment to Fight Coronavirus by VOA News
Updates: Florida Governor, Shifting Course, Tells Residents to Stay Home by NYT
Protective Gear in National Stockpile is Nearly Depleted, DHS Officials Say by WaPo
Florida Issues Statewide Limits as US Cases Mount by WSJ
Coronavirus: Greatest Test Since World War Two, Says UN Chief by BBC News
Book Review Roundtable: Understanding Proxy Warfare by Texas National Security Review
Top Marine Says Light Armored Reconnaissance is Outmoded on Future Battlefield by Marine Corps Times
US Navy Evacuating Virus-Struck Aircraft Carrier Roosevelt by Agence France Presse
Trump Warns Iran Will Pay a ‘Very Heavy Price’ if its Forces or Proxies Attack US Troops by Military Times
Coast Guard: Cruise Ships Must Stay at Sea with Sick Onboard by Navy Times
The Naval War College Ran a Pandemic War Game in 2019. The Conclusions Were Eerie by Military.com
AFRICOM Plans Quarterly Reports on Possible Civilian Casualties as New Allegations Emerge by Stars & Stripes
Navy VCNO Says Deployed Operations Will Continue Amid COVID-19 Pandemic by Navy Times
US Military Furloughs Thousands of South Korean Workers by VOA News
China Concealed Extent of Virus Outbreak, US Intelligence Says by Bloomberg
Special Operations News Update – Wednesday, April 1, 2020 by SOF News
Footer menu
About
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Site Help
Contact
©2005-2018
Small Wars Journal is published by Small Wars Foundation - a 501(c)(3) non-profit corporation.
Original content is published under a Creative Commons License per our Terms of Use.
Creative Commons
© Copyright 2020 | Site by 3C Web Services